The Farmer's Dog vs Ollie vs Nom Nom: Fresh Dog Food Compared (2026)
PawSmart is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. This never affects our recommendations.
How we choose our recommendations. PawSmart is independent and reader-supported. We shortlist products by researching manufacturer specifications, published safety standards, veterinary and professional-trainer guidance, and the pattern across thousands of verified owner reviews — then we favour the options with the best balance of safety, durability and real-world value. We don’t accept payment for placement, our picks are the same whether or not a brand runs an affiliate program, and when something isn’t worth your money we say so.
The Farmer's Dog, Ollie, and Nom Nom are the three biggest names in fresh, human-grade dog food delivery — and their websites make them look almost identical. All three cook real ingredients gently, portion meals to your dog's exact profile, and ship them frozen to your door on a subscription. But once you look past the near-matching marketing, they diverge in recipe variety, how the food is formulated, and — most importantly — what you'll actually pay each month. Here's an honest head-to-head to help you pick.
What all three have in common
Before the differences, the shared promise: human-grade ingredients (the same quality standard as food made for people), gently cooked at low temperatures to preserve nutrients, then frozen and pre-portioned to your dog's weight, age, and calorie needs from a short onboarding quiz. All three meet AAFCO nutritional standards, all three offer a discounted trial box, and all three are a clear step up in ingredient quality from most kibble. They are also all premium-priced — this is the most expensive way to feed a dog, and it is not the right choice for every household or budget.
Fresh food vs kibble: the honest trade-offs
Fresh food's upsides are real: recognisable whole ingredients, no fillers or artificial preservatives, precise portioning that helps with weight control, and high palatability for picky eaters. Many owners also report better coats, energy, and firmer stool. The downsides are just as real: it costs far more than kibble, it takes up freezer space, it has a short fridge life once thawed, and for large breeds the per-day cost compounds quickly. Kibble remains a perfectly healthy, convenient, budget-friendly option — fresh food is an upgrade, not a requirement. Whichever way you go, transition gradually over 7–10 days to avoid stomach upset, and consult your vet before switching a dog with a health condition, allergy, or special dietary need.
Head-to-head comparison
| The Farmer's Dog | Ollie | Nom Nom | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Food style | Fully fresh, gently cooked, frozen | Fresh cooked, plus baked & mixed-bowl options | Fully fresh, gently cooked, portion-precise |
| Recipes | A focused core lineup of simple, few-ingredient recipes | Widest variety — several proteins across fresh and baked lines | A small, tightly controlled set of vet-developed recipes |
| Personalization | Portions and calories tailored from an onboarding quiz | Profile-based recipes with strong sourcing transparency | Developed with a veterinary nutritionist; precise per-meal portioning |
| Price | $$$ — premium; transparent post-trial cost | $$$ — premium; format choice can lower cost | $$$ — premium; among the more expensive per day |
| Best for | Best overall & simplicity | Best recipe variety & picky eaters | Best vet-developed & portion precision |
The verdict on each
The Farmer's Dog
The best-known name in fresh delivery, and our overall pick for most people. The recipes are simple and few-ingredient, the onboarding portions food precisely to your dog, and the post-trial cost is refreshingly transparent — you know what you'll pay before you commit. It doesn't chase variety or clinical extras; it just does the core job cleanly, which is exactly why it's the easiest service to recommend to a first-time fresh-food buyer.
Visit The Farmer's Dog →Ollie
Ollie offers the broadest menu of the three — multiple fresh proteins plus baked and mixed-bowl formats — which makes it the standout for picky eaters or dogs that get bored of one recipe. It publishes clear ingredient and sourcing information, and the format flexibility means you can sometimes keep the cost down without dropping to kibble. If recipe rotation matters in your house, Ollie is the one to try first.
Visit Ollie →Nom Nom
Nom Nom was developed with input from a veterinary nutritionist and leans hardest into a science-forward, portion-precise approach, with pre-measured fresh meals and gut-health add-ons. It's the pick for owners who want recipes with clear clinical grounding and exact per-meal control — helpful for weight management or dogs with specific needs. It tends to sit at the pricier end, and any special diet should still be confirmed with your own vet.
Visit Nom Nom →See current trial-box offers
View Offers →So which should you pick?
For most owners, The Farmer's Dog is the safest first bet: simple recipes, precise portioning, and honest pricing. Choose Ollie if your dog is picky or you want recipe variety and format flexibility. Choose Nom Nom if you value a vet-developed formulation and exact portion control, and the higher cost fits your budget. If full fresh food stretches your budget, remember there's no shame in a high-quality kibble, an air-dried option, or using fresh food as a topper rather than the whole bowl. The best food is the complete, balanced one you can afford consistently — and that your dog thrives on.
Frequently asked questions
Which is best — The Farmer's Dog, Ollie, or Nom Nom?
We rate The Farmer's Dog best overall for its simple recipes, precise portioning, and transparent pricing. Ollie is best for recipe variety and picky eaters, and Nom Nom is best for a vet-developed, portion-precise approach. The right one depends on your dog's tastes, size, and your budget.
Is fresh dog food actually worth the extra cost?
For small-to-medium dogs whose budget allows, fresh food is a genuine quality upgrade, and many owners report better coats, energy, and stool. For large breeds the monthly cost can be steep — a topper plan, air-dried food, or a premium kibble may make more financial sense. It's an upgrade, not a requirement.
How do I switch my dog to fresh food?
Transition gradually over 7–10 days, mixing an increasing proportion of the new fresh food with the current food to avoid digestive upset. Slow the pace if you notice loose stool, and consult your vet first if your dog has a health condition.
Does fresh dog food need to be kept frozen?
Yes. Fully fresh meals from all three services ship frozen and must stay frozen until a few days before serving, then refrigerated — so you need freezer space. Ollie's baked line is more shelf-stable than the fully fresh meals.
Are these safe for a dog with a health condition?
All three meet AAFCO standards, but a dog with a medical condition, allergy, or special dietary need should be switched only after talking to your vet. Share the recipe's full ingredient panel with them so they can confirm it suits your dog.
⚕️ A note on advice: This article is general guidance to help you make informed decisions — it is not a substitute for professional veterinary advice. Always consult your vet about your dog's individual health and needs.
Trusted resources for further reading
We recommend these respected organizations for authoritative, vet-reviewed information: American Kennel Club (AKC), ASPCA, and the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA).